Biovail Advises Shareholders to Use Their Blue Proxy to Reject Melnyk Nominees
Notes that Dissident Melnyk Has Acted to Frustrate Shareholder Democracy
TORONTO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--May. 14, 2009--
Biovail Corporation (NYSE:BVF)(TSX:BVF) today issued a letter to
shareholders, providing them with further reasons to use their BLUE
proxy to vote for the Biovail nominees to the Board of Directors and to
reject the two nominees proposed by dissident shareholder Eugene Melnyk.
In light of steps taken by Mr. Melnyk to obstruct voting by
non-registered shareholders, the letter also includes important
information about voting at the Company’s Annual and Special Meeting of
Shareholders scheduled for 10:00 a.m. Eastern Time, on Thursday, May 28,
2009.
Mr. Melnyk has stated he will not pursue any of his eight dissident
resolutions that were purportedly aimed at corporate governance
practices. He has also said he will not oppose the Company’s other
resolutions. As a result, the key questions to be decided at the Meeting
have been reduced to whether shareholders want to see Mr. Melnyk’s two
nominees placed on the Board at the expense of losing two current
Directors who have been among the most important contributors to
Biovail’s return to being a growth company.
The letter notes that neither of the Melnyk nominees provide any
experience or expertise that is not already available on the Biovail
Board. Both nominees lack experience in the pharmaceutical industry and
would require time to gain an understanding of Biovail and its changing
industry while the Company must move forward rapidly to implement its
New Strategic Focus.
The text of the letter Biovail sent to shareholders today follows:
May 14, 2009
|
Annual and Special Meeting
|
|
May 28, 2009
|
|
10:00 a.m. (Eastern Time)
|
|
Glenn Gould Studio, CBC Canadian Broadcasting Centre,
|
|
250 Front Street West, Toronto.
|
|
Â
|
Dear Fellow Shareholder of Biovail Corporation:
With your company’s Annual and Special Meeting only days away, you have
an important decision to make about the future of Biovail.
Essentially, you will be deciding whether Biovail should build on the
successes of the past year under the guidance of the Biovail nominees to
the Board of Directors. You can support this Board or you can allow
dissident shareholder Eugene Melnyk to again attempt to exert undue
influence over the Company and to continue to divert Biovail’s resources
and efforts from its primary goal – increasing long-term value for
shareholders.
We believe your decision has been made easier by Mr. Melnyk’s recent
actions:
-
He has cleared away what we previously called the “smokescreen” of his
eight resolutions on corporate governance. After insisting on
shareholder votes on each of them, Mr. Melnyk announced he would focus
on only four and then announced he was withdrawing his support for all
of his own resolutions;
-
He has now named his two nominees to the Board. They offer no
expertise or experience that is not already provided by the Biovail
nominees. Replacing two accomplished directors with the Melnyk
nominees would dilute, rather than strengthen, your Board;
-
He has targeted two of Biovail’s most experienced and active Directors
for removal from the Board; they were also two of the principal
architects of the Company’s New Strategic Focus which has helped make
Biovail a growth company once again; and
-
He has also attempted to undermine shareholder democracy at Biovail by
creating procedural roadblocks to voting at the Annual and Special
Meeting.
We do not intend to revisit all the facts we provided in the Management
Proxy Circular and the accompanying letter of April 21st.
However, we want to ensure you are informed about these recent
developments before you cast your important vote at the Annual and
Special Meeting.
Eugene Melnyk Will Not Be Asking For A Vote On His Corporate
Governance Resolutions
Mr. Melnyk is no longer seeking approval for his eight resolutions
requiring changes to corporate governance practices at Biovail. This may
indicate his recognition that some of his desired changes were
unnecessary after the steady improvement in corporate governance since
he left the Company. It may demonstrate his realization that Biovail
today follows the highest standards in corporate governance and is now
independently ranked in the top 98th percentile in its
industry. We believe the resolutions as proposed were not in
shareholders’ interests and were unlikely to be approved.
Despite withdrawing his support for his own corporate governance
resolutions, Mr. Melnyk is seeking your support for his nominees
because he claims they are needed to help improve corporate governance
at Biovail – without providing any specifics on what areas he believes
need improvement.
Mr. Melnyk says he is no longer trying to change Biovail’s direction,
strategy, or management. He is no longer requiring or supporting votes
that would change corporate governance. Yet he says he wants his two
nominees on the Board –supposedly to enhance corporate governance.
However, his nominees have no more demonstrable expertise than the
current members of the Board.
Eugene Melnyk’s Nominees Would Not Add to Biovail’s Experienced and
Capable Board
We do not intend to question the business experience or ethics of Mr.
Melnyk’s nominees. They have had notable careers. However, neither of
them fill a gap or satisfy a need in the current Board. We believe it is
important that shareholders recognize these facts about the Melnyk
nominees:
-
They are Mr. Melnyk’s nominees. Whatever their claims of
independence, they would not be standing for election without Mr.
Melnyk;
-
They have no experience in the pharmaceutical industry, or with
Biovail’s New Strategic Focus;
-
Their experience on the boards of Canadian public companies does not
compare to the experience of the Biovail Board;
-
They appear to have limited business experience in the United States,
where Biovail generates approximately 90% of its business and revenue,
or on the boards of companies that are registered in the United
States, as Biovail is;
-
The Melnyk nominees do not appear to have “demonstrable experience in
successfully leading public companies through periods of significant
change”. This is the standard Mr. Melnyk uses to argue for the
replacement of two existing Biovail directors; and
-
Their other board relationships may not meet Biovail’s Corporate
Governance standards because, if elected, the Melnyk nominees would be
serving together on three public or quasi-public boards. This is also
not consistent with Canadian Coalition for Good Governance Guidelines
which state that too many “interlocking directorships” – when
directors of one company also sit on the board of a second company
--”suggests a degree of inter-related interests that may be
detrimental to director independence”.
Biovail already has a distinguished and experienced Board of Directors,
a strong team which is proving its ability to implement change and
deliver shareholder value. The two Melnyk nominees would not improve the
Board but would pose a real risk to its effectiveness as they take time
to learn about Biovail while the industry continues to change rapidly
and opportunities need to be considered promptly.
Eugene Melnyk Has Launched Misguided Attacks Against Current Directors
In his attempt to get his nominees on to the Board, Mr. Melnyk is
proposing removing two, more experienced, Directors; Michael Van Every
and Dr. Laurence Paul. This is simply not in the best interests of
shareholders. While Mr. Melnyk claims the current Board members “owe
much to current management” the fact is that Mr. Van Every and Dr. Paul
actually joined the Board when Mr. Melnyk was Chairman or CEO of Biovail.
Both were members of the Independent Committee that oversaw development
and implementation of the Company’s New Strategic Focus. Both also
served on the Committee responsible for changes to compensation policies
and the improved corporate governance at Biovail. Both served as chair
of the audit committee during the periods the Company was trying to
address financial issues that were rooted in Mr. Melnyk’s time as the
head of Biovail. These Directors owe nothing to current management. In
fact, the opposite is true. They accepted the challenge of leading the
development of the New Strategic Focus that management is implementing
to transform Biovail.
Eugene Melnyk is Attempting to Frustrate Shareholder Democracy at
Biovail – Again.
Consistent with his efforts to impede shareholder democracy at last
year’s annual meeting, Mr. Melnyk is exploiting a technicality to make
it more difficult for Biovail shareholders to vote their shares at this
year’s meeting. Here’s what he has done this time:
-
Mr. Melnyk’s dissident form of proxy listed 13 directors for election,
rather than 11 -- the number established by the Board to be elected by
the shareholders at the May 28th meeting. Simply by choosing to format
his form of proxy in this unnecessary way, Mr Melnyk has
deliberately caused Broadridge, the independent third party that
collects votes from non-registered shareholders, to eliminate
electronic voting (telephone or internet) for Biovail shareholders who
wish to use the BLUE Biovail proxy (or voting instruction form). This
can discourage voting and disrupt the voting process;
-
Last year, Mr. Melnyk used electronic voting as he solicited proxies
for his dissident slate of directors. Electronic voting, rather than
mail or fax, is generally accepted as the preferred way to vote
because it is simpler and easier for shareholders. More than 91% of
the 195 billion shares voted through Broadridge in 2008, were voted
electronically. Elimination of electronic voting is virtually
unprecedented in Canadian proxy contests;
-
Mr. Melnyk’s calculated and deliberate preparation of his form of
proxy, which has forced Broadridge to terminate electronic voting,
could result in a significant number of shares not being voted at the
May 28th meeting. It appears he is again saying one thing
and doing another. He has indicated he intends to support Management’s
resolution reducing the quorum for annual meetings from 51% to a more
usual and reasonable 25%. Yet he is acting to prevent the submission
of the necessary votes to pass the resolution; in effect using the
existing quorum requirement to defeat efforts to modify it or to
approve any of the rest of the business of the meeting. Alternatively,
Mr Melnyk may be attempting to enhance the voting power of
his shareholdings due to a reduced voter turnout; and
-
We believe this is yet another example of Mr. Melnyk acting in his own
self interests, and not in the best interests of all shareholders.
On behalf of shareholders, Biovail is currently reviewing and
considering all available legal remedies on electronic voting. In the
interim, non-registered shareholders should vote their BLUE proxy
by either fax or mail, depending if they live in Canada or the United
States. They should contact their broker or intermediary to ensure that
their voting instruction form is properly sent to Broadridge.
Shareholders with any questions about how to vote their shares, should
contact our proxy solicitation agent Georgeson: toll-free in North
America at 1-866-676-3028 (Bank and broker and collect calls:
1-212-806-6859).
Do NOT let Mr. Melnyk succeed in his deliberate attempt to frustrate the
receipt and processing of your vote. Please submit your voting
instruction form or BLUE proxy by fax or mail today.
Your vote helps determine the future of Biovail and provides your Board
with the opportunity to continue to pursue the Company’s successful New
Strategic Focus. Your Board has led the Company through significant and
positive changes since being elected last year. It has strengthened
senior management and undertaken a restructuring and cost
rationalization program designed to increase efficiency and
profitability. It has completed a strategically important acquisition
and added cash-producing product lines. It has enhanced Biovail’s
corporate governance practices to meet or exceed North American
regulatory and independent advisory group standards. Most significantly
for you – in the face of the most difficult capital markets in
generations, it has delivered value for shareholders.
It is illogical and counterproductive to overturn the progress Biovail
has made since Eugene Melnyk left the Company in order to allow him to
again exercise influence over your Company.
His dissident circular says “Mr. Melnyk has moved on – and is not
interested in a fight with Biovail”. It would be better for other
shareholders if this were true. Unfortunately, Mr. Melnyk has returned
to impede the Company’s progress with short-lived nuisance resolutions.
He threatens the integrity of the Board that has served shareholders
well and is attempting to undermine the very process used by
shareholders to elect the Directors who protect their interests.
We believe your best interests are served by once again telling Mr.
Melnyk his interference in Biovail is unwelcome. We ask you to vote the
BLUE proxy in favour of the Biovail Nominees and the Biovail resolutions
in time to be counted at the Annual and Special Meeting.
Yours sincerely,
|
[signature]
|
Â
|
Â
|
Â
|
Â
|
Â
|
Â
|
Â
|
Â
|
Â
|
Â
|
[signature]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Â
|
|
Dr. Douglas J.P. Squires
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
William M. Wells
|
|
Chairman of the Board
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Chief Executive Officer
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Â
|
[Text ends]
As a result of the technical maneuvers of Mr. Melnyk in the preparation
of his form of proxy, shareholders are advised to review the follow
voting instructions:
Your Vote is Important - THE PROXY TO VOTE IS BLUE - Vote Today
To ensure your vote is counted, completed BLUE proxies must be
received by 10:00 a.m. May 26, 2009.
NON-REGISTERED HOLDERS:
CANADA: vote by FAX or, if necessary, by mail using the prepaid
envelope provided.
UNITED STATES: vote by mail, using the envelope provided.
INSTITUTIONAL HOLDERS UTILIZING THE PROXYEDGE SYSTEM CAN CONTINUE TO
DO SO USING THE BLUE PROXY.
REGISTERED HOLDERS:
Due to the limited time available, we recommend voting the BLUE
proxy using either internet or telephone voting or one of the other
available methods.
Shareholders with questions or needing assistance in voting their BLUE
proxy are encouraged to call Biovail’s Proxy Solicitation Agent,
Georgeson at:
North American Toll-Free:1-866-676-3028 Bank and Broker
and collect calls accepted: 1-212-806-6859
Even if you have already voted using the dissident proxy, you have every
right to change your vote simply by executing the BLUE form of
proxy: It is the later-dated proxy that
will be counted.
Caution Regarding Forward-Looking Information and “Safe Harbor”
Statement
To the extent any statements made in this release contain information
that is not historical, these statements are forward-looking statements
within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, as
amended, and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as
amended, and may be forward-looking information within the meaning
defined under applicable Canadian securities legislation (collectively,
"forward-looking statements"). These forward-looking statements relate
to, among other things, our objectives, goals, targets, strategies,
intentions, plans, beliefs, estimates and outlook, and can generally be
identified by the use of words such as "believe", "anticipate",
"expect", "intend", "plan", "will", "may", "target" and other similar
expressions. In addition, any statements that refer to expectations,
projections or other characterizations of future events or circumstances
are forward-looking statements.
Although Biovail believes that the expectations reflected in such
forward-looking statements are reasonable, such statements involve risks
and uncertainties and readers are cautioned not to place undue reliance
on such statements. Certain material factors or assumptions are applied
in making forward-looking statements, and actual results may differ
materially from those expressed or implied in such statements. Important
factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from these
expectations include, among other things, the risks detailed in our
Management Proxy Circular and from time to time in our filings with the
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and the Canadian Securities
Administrators, as well as our ability to anticipate and manage the
risks associated with the foregoing. Additional information about these
factors and about the material factors or assumptions underlying such
forward-looking statements may be found in the body of this news
release, as well as under the heading "Risk Factors" contained in Item
3.D of Biovail's most recent Annual Report on Form 20-F.
The Company cautions that the foregoing list of important factors that
may affect future results is not exhaustive. When relying on Biovail's
forward-looking statements to make decisions with respect to the
Company, investors and others should carefully consider the foregoing
factors and other uncertainties and potential events. Biovail undertakes
no obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statement, except
as required by law.
About Biovail Corporation
Biovail Corporation is a specialty pharmaceutical company engaged in the
formulation, clinical testing, registration, manufacture, and
commercialization of pharmaceutical products. The Company is focused on
the development and commercialization of medicines that address unmet
medical needs in niche specialty central nervous system (CNS) markets.
For more information about Biovail, visit the Company’s web site at www.biovail.com.
For further information, please contact Nelson F. Isabel at 905-286-3000
or send inquiries to ir@biovail.com.
Source: Biovail Corporation
Biovail Corporation Nelson F. Isabel, (905) 286-3000 Vice
President, Investor Relations & Corporate Communications
|