Biovail Issues Management Proxy Circular and Letter to Shareholders
Urges Shareholders to Vote the BLUE Proxy and Oppose the Melnyk Nominees And Resolutions
TORONTO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Apr. 30, 2009--
Biovail Corporation (NYSE, TSX: BVF) today announced that it has
mailed
to shareholders its Notice of Annual and Special Meeting of Shareholders
and Management Proxy Circular for the Company's meeting scheduled for
10:00 a.m. Eastern Time, on Thursday, May 28, 2009 in the Glenn Gould
Studio of the CBC Canadian Broadcasting Centre, 250 Front Street West,
Toronto, Ontario.
"Biovail's Board of Directors unanimously recommends that shareholders
vote only the BLUE proxy in favour of the Biovail nominees to the
Board
of Directors and the Company's resolutions," said Douglas Squires,
Chairman of the Biovail Board of Directors.
"Over the past year, the current Board has guided Biovail through a
period of significant strategic and operating progress and has improved
value for shareholders, despite facing the most challenging capital
markets in decades," said Biovail Chief Executive Officer Bill
Wells.
"We significantly strengthened our senior management team and have taken
a number of steps to restructure Biovail aimed at improving
efficiencies. We are also on track with our New Strategic Focus - we
acquired our first specialty CNS product in September 2008 and are in
active discussions for the in-licensing or acquisition of others.
"Unfortunately, dissident shareholder Eugene Melnyk, the Company's
former Chairman and CEO, is once again attempting to exert undue
influence over the affairs of Biovail by proposing two of his own
personally chosen nominees for the Board," Mr. Wells said. "Mr. Melnyk
has also proposed eight dissident resolutions purporting to address
corporate governance; however, these proposals are based on Mr. Melnyk's
flawed and outdated understanding of corporate governance at Biovail.
In
fact, Biovail now adheres to the highest standards of corporate
governance."
In the Management Proxy circular, the Board of Directors unanimously
recommends that shareholders vote only the BLUE proxy:
FOR the election of the 11 director nominees proposed by Biovail
in the Management Proxy Circular
FOR the re-appointment of Ernst & Young LLP as our auditors and
the authorization of the directors to fix the auditors' remuneration
FOR the approval of amendments to Biovail's By-law
FOR the approval of amendments to Biovail's 2007 Equity
Compensation Plan
AGAINST all resolutions proposed by Mr. Melnyk
Copies of the Management Proxy Circular, the letter to shareholders and
voting instructions are available at the Company's website www.biovail.com
or at www.sedar.com.
The full text of the letter Biovail sent to shareholders today
follows:
April 21, 2009
Dear Fellow Shareholder of Biovail Corporation
Your Company has made remarkable progress in the past year. We have
moved ahead with the implementation of Biovail's New Strategic Focus,
strengthened the Board of Directors and management team, added new
product revenue streams, restructured to improve efficiency, and
increased returns to shareholders. We have also taken major strides in
improving corporate governance - to the point where Biovail is now
independently ranked in the top 98th percentile in
its industry.
We look forward to reporting to you on these and other positive
developments at Biovail's Annual and Special Meeting which will be held
at 10:00 a.m. (Eastern time) on Thursday May 28, 2009 in the Glenn Gould
Studio of the CBC Canadian Broadcasting Centre, 250 Front Street West,
Toronto, Ontario. Whether or not you are able to
attend in person,
please submit your BLUE proxy by 10:00 a.m. (Eastern time) on
May 26, 2009.
At this year's annual meeting, your vote will be especially important
because, unfortunately, dissident shareholder Eugene Melnyk, the
Company's former Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, is once again
attempting to exert undue influence over the affairs of your Company.
After his unsuccessful effort to install his own Board at last year's
annual meeting, Mr. Melnyk and a company he controls have requisitioned
a "special meeting" so he can nominate two individuals of his choosing
to the Board. Creating a smokescreen of "corporate governance" issues,
he is also proposing eight separate resolutions to be voted on by
shareholders.
Your Board believes that neither the election of two Melnyk nominees nor
the adoption of the Melnyk resolutions would be in the best interests of
Biovail or its shareholders. Despite our recent success, Mr. Melnyk is
on record as opposing our New Strategic Focus; placing his nominees on
the Board would serve only to delay or frustrate Biovail's progress. The
dissident resolutions are unnecessary, misguided and counterproductive.
The Board of Directors unanimously recommends that you vote only the BLUE proxy:
FOR the election of the 11 director nominees proposed by Biovail
in the Management Proxy Circular. Do NOT Vote for the dissident
nominees
FOR the re-appointment of Ernst & Young LLP as our auditors and
the authorization of the directors to fix the auditors' remuneration
FOR the approval of amendments to Biovail's By-law
FOR the approval of amendments to Biovail's 2007 Equity
Compensation Plan
AGAINST all eight resolutions proposed by Mr. Melnyk
Details about each of these resolutions and the reasons for the Board's
recommendations are provided in the Management Proxy Circular. We
encourage you to review the Management Proxy Circular and vote your BLUE
proxy as soon as possible.
Disregard any materials you may receive from any party other than the
Company.
Here we can offer you a summary of the issues to be determined and your
Board's views:
The Election of Directors:
Reasons to Vote For the
11 Biovail Nominees to the Board
Biovail's 11 nominees to the Board of Directors are the 10 incumbent
Board members with the significant addition of Sir Louis Tull.
Effectively, this is the same Board that was overwhelmingly elected at
last year's annual meeting and the first Biovail Board to be fully
independent of Eugene Melnyk.
Over the past year, your current Board has guided Biovail through a
period of significant strategic and operating progress - and has
improved value for shareholders. Under your current Board's direction,
Biovail has:
-
Appointed Bill Wells as Chief Executive Officer of the Company
-
Launched the implementation of the Company's New Strategic Focus on
niche specialty central nervous system (CNS) products
-
Strengthened the senior management team with the appointment of a new
Chief Financial Officer and new Chief Scientific Officer, among others
-
Initiated a restructuring and cost rationalization program intended to
significantly increase the Company's efficiency and profitability
-
Created an External Advisory Board to provide medical, scientific and
commercial guidance for Biovail's product development pipeline
-
Completed the acquisition of Prestwick Pharmaceuticals, which
accelerated Biovail's entry into the specialty CNS marketplace
-
Launched Xenazine® in the U.S. market, the only
U.S.-approved treatment of chorea associated with Huntington's disease
and the only FDA-approved treatment for any symptom of Huntington's
disease
-
Signed a significant supply and distribution agreement with an
industry leading commercialization partner and launched Aplenzin®
in the U.S. market
-
Settled Biovail's sixth major "legacy" litigation/regulatory matter
related to the time period when Mr. Melnyk was Chairman or Chief
Executive Officer of the Company
-
Further enhanced its corporate governance policies and practices
-
Announced improved financial results for the 2008 fourth quarter and
full year
Most importantly, led by your current Board, Biovail has delivered
value - despite facing the most challenging capital markets in decades.
Total Shareholder Return
Photos/Multimedia Gallery Available: http://www.businesswire.com/cgi-bin/mmg.cgi?eid=5953916&lang=en
Reasons to Vote Against
the Melnyk Nominees
Given Mr. Melnyk's past record with the Company - which is described in
detail in the Management Proxy Circular - Biovail shareholders should
be
justifiably concerned about whose interests his nominees would serve.
Mr. Melnyk is opposed to Biovail's New Strategic Focus and has publicly
referred to it as "ill-conceived". Despite the clear early signs of
success for the strategy, and expressions of support from independent
industry analysts, Mr. Melnyk's nominees could be expected to bring his
opposition into the Board room. The result could be a dysfunctional
Board, unable to drive the Company forward to the kinds of results that
shareholders have a right to expect. Differing viewpoints and a level of
debate about execution are to be expected and encouraged among the Board
members. However, the Board needs to be united behind an agreed
strategy, particularly in an economic climate as challenging as that
facing North America today.
Your Board believes that the Melnyk nominees could be a potentially
divisive element on the Board and destructive to long-term shareholder
value.
The Dissident Resolutions
Mr. Melnyk has also proposed eight resolutions related to Biovail's
corporate governance. We recommend that shareholders reject all of these
resolutions for the reasons set out in Schedule 4 of the Management
Proxy Circular. We have summarized our recommendations below:
Reasons to Vote:
Against Dissident
Resolution No. 1
Mr. Melnyk proposes that Biovail should alter its By-law so that the
Company would be required to adopt any "majority voting" policy
of the Canadian Coalition for Good Governance ("CCGG"). Biovail's Board
has already approved amendments to its Corporate Governance Guidelines
to adopt a "majority voting" policy that is consistent with the CCGG
model majority voting policy. Mr. Melnyk's proposal that Biovail
automatically
adopt any future CCGG "majority voting" policy - sight unseen -
is contrary to the Board's duty to consider and act in the best
interests of shareholders and would be an improper derogation of the
Board's duties and responsibilities. Such an approach would be
inconsistent with the governance practices of other major Canadian
companies.
Against Dissident
Resolutions No. 2 and 3
These two resolutions would limit the indemnification Biovail can
offer
to its existing and future directors and officers. This would hinder the
Company's ability to attract and retain qualified individuals by
exposing them to greater legal liability even when they are acting in
the best interests of shareholders. Biovail's current By-law and
individual indemnification arrangements provide the proper balance
between protecting Biovail and its directors and officers. We believe
that what Mr. Melnyk is proposing is misinformed, unprecedented in
Canada, runs counter to the recommendations of major
institutional
investors, and is not in the best interests of shareholders. We also
note that, to date, Biovail has paid over US$4 million more than its
D&O
insurance policy covers to indemnify one former officer and director -
Eugene Melnyk.
Against Dissident
Resolution No. 4
If adopted, this resolution would require Biovail - and all of its
shareholders - to reimburse any shareholder who owns at least 5% of the
Company's shares for the cost of nominating alternative directors and
soliciting proxies on their behalf. Current Canadian securities laws
provide ample opportunity for major shareholders to propose alternative
directors. This resolution would, in effect, mean continued disruptive,
divisive and expensive director elections which would allow Mr. Melnyk -
as a shareholder who owns more than 5% of Biovail's shares - to continue
to nominate potential directors to represent his interests, but have
you, the shareholders, pay the significant costs arising from
his actions.
Against Dissident
Resolution No. 5
There is no reason to consider adopting this resolution to allow
shareholders to vote their proxies for individual directors rather than
entire slates. Biovail's Corporate Governance Guidelines have provided
for the election of individual directors at shareholder meetings since
2005. The election of slates of directors occurs only at contested
meetings, such as the one that Mr. Melnyk caused for Biovail in 2008.
Against Dissident
Resolution No. 6
Your Board believes that this resolution, which would place significant
restrictions on Biovail's ability to pursue and complete strategic
transactions, is not in the best interests of shareholders. It would
place the Company at a disadvantage by adding shareholder approval as a
condition to many potential transactions - a condition not faced by
other companies and that would add costs and create uncertainty around
completion. It could also allow certain shareholders to use the approval
requirement for their own, conflicted, purposes and prevent the Board
from acting in the best interests of all shareholders. Appropriate
protections for Biovail shareholders are already in place - for
example,
the Company has voluntarily adopted the New York Stock Exchange
guidelines requiring shareholder approval in the event of any
transaction that would dilute shareholders by 20% or more. Far from
being an improvement, this dissident resolution would place Biovail at
a
significant competitive disadvantage and would likely inhibit growth and
enhancement of shareholder value.
Against Dissident
Resolution No. 7
The premise of this resolution is that corporate governance policies,
structures and procedures at Biovail continue to be as weak as they
were
when Mr. Melnyk was Chairman or Chief Executive Officer of the Company.
This premise is wrong. Biovail's Statement of Corporate Governance
Practices, which is set out in Appendix A in the Management Proxy
Circular, clearly demonstrates that Biovail adheres to the highest
standards of corporate governance. While this was not the case during
the Melnyk years, today Biovail is in full or substantial compliance
with 98% of the CCGG corporate governance guidelines' minimum standards.
Furthermore, RiskMetrics Group Inc., a leading independent corporate
governance and proxy advisory firm, reported in April 2009 that
Biovail's corporate governance practices outperformed more than 88% of
the companies included in the S&P/TSX Composite Index and more than 98%
of the companies in the Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology and Life Sciences
group on corporate governance matters.
The current Board has implemented more changes to corporate governance
than Mr. Melnyk seems to recognize and has done so without derogating
its responsibility to consider recommendations made from time to time by
a third party, a derogation of duty that Mr. Melnyk recommends. The
Board remains committed to continuous improvement in corporate
governance at Biovail, by Biovail, and for all
Biovail shareholders.
Against Dissident
Resolution No. 8
Adoption of either of the two parts of this resolution would move
Biovail well away from Canadian standards for termination payments to
management. The first part of this resolution would require the Company
to amend all of its employment agreements to include specific Company
performance targets. If Biovail did not achieve those targets, the
executive could be terminated without severance - even if the executive
was not directly responsible for the Company falling short. Such an
approach would make management vulnerable to unpredictable external
factors that may be well beyond the control of the Company or an
individual executive. This would be unfair and unworkable and would make
attracting qualified executives to Biovail and retaining them much
more
difficult. Reducing the availability of talented people who are willing
to work at the Company is not in shareholders' best interests.
The second part of this resolution relates to terminations resulting
from a change of control. Biovail's practice, now reflected in the
policies of the Compensation Committee Charter, is to provide for
severance payments only if there has been a change of control and
the executive is terminated as a result of that change of control within
12 months of that change. This "double trigger" policy is in line with
market practice, as is the 12 months specified by the Charter.
Biovail's future success is in your hands
In the days leading up to the May 28, 2009 Annual and Special Meeting,
Biovail shareholders will, once again, have to decide on the course
their Company will take. We believe that choice is clear. It is between
an effective, proven and independent Board that will continue to pursue
the New Strategic Focus and value creation for all shareholders - or a
Board potentially divided by Eugene Melnyk's misguided and intransigent
opposition to a promising new strategic direction.
We also believe that the Melnyk resolutions are, in fact, a diversion
from Mr. Melnyk's central aim - to get personal representation on the
Board of Directors and increase his influence over Biovail's affairs and
resources. His resolutions are based on a flawed and outdated
understanding of corporate governance at Biovail as it exists today
and
a failure to recognize your current Board's commitment to continue to
meet best practices and evolving standards. The resolutions proposed by
Mr. Melnyk are, to varying degrees, impractical, irrelevant, unwarranted
and overly restrictive. Their overall effect would be to erode Biovail's
competitiveness. Despite their stated aim, the dissident resolutions are
an ill-conceived attempt to direct unfounded criticism at Biovail's
corporate governance in order to generate support for Mr. Melnyk's
desire to place his two nominees on the Board. They do not benefit all
Biovail shareholders.
Biovail shareholders sent Mr. Melnyk a clear and strong message last
year. For all the reasons summarized here - and provided in full in the
Management Proxy Circular - we encourage you to repeat that unequivocal
message again this year. We are asking you to act in your own best
interests by voting the BLUE proxy in favour of the Biovail nominees
and
to reject the Melnyk resolutions.
Yours sincerely,
|
Dr. Douglas J.P Squires
|
|
|
|
|
William M. Wells
|
|
Chairman of the Board
|
|
|
|
|
Chief Executive Officer
|
Biovail Shareholders: The Proxy To Vote Is Blue
Your Vote Is Extremely Important, No Matter How Many Shares You Own
The Annual and Special Meeting of Shareholders of Biovail Corporation
will be held at 10:00 a.m. on Thursday May 28, 2009 in the Glenn Gould
Studio of the CBC Canadian Broadcasting Centre, 250 Front Street West,
Toronto. Please submit your BLUE proxy by 10:00 a.m.
(Toronto time)
on May 26, 2009.
TIME IS SHORT - VOTE TODAY.
YOUR BOARD RECOMMENDS THAT YOU:
|
VOTE ONLY YOUR BLUE PROXY
|
|
|
FOR the election of the 11 Biovail directors
|
|
|
FOR the re-appointment of the auditors
|
|
|
FOR the By-law amendments
|
|
|
FOR the 2007 Equity Compensation Plan amendments
|
|
|
AGAINST all eight resolutions proposed by Mr. Melnyk
|
Voting is a very quick and easy process. To be effective, your BLUE
proxy must be received no later than 10:00 a.m. (Toronto Time)
May 26, 2009, using any one of the methods described on the BLUE
form of proxy. Due to the limited time available, we recommend voting by
internet, telephone or facsimile.
Whether or not you plan to attend the meeting, please complete and
return the BLUE proxy
promptly. Discard any materials that you may receive other than from
Biovail.
Shareholders with questions or needing assistance in voting their BLUE
proxy should call Georgeson:
North American Toll Free Number: 1-866-676-3028
Banks and Broker and Collect Calls Accepted: 1-212-806-6859
Europe Toll Free*: 00 800 6611 6611 (*Austria; Belgium;
Denmark; Finland; France; Germany; Ireland;
Italy; Netherlands;
Norway; Spain; Sweden; Switzerland; United Kingdom)
Europe Collect: +44 117 378 6025
Please visit our website for regular updates at www.biovail.com
The Company will not be commenting further on this matter at this time.
Caution Regarding Forward-Looking Information and "Safe Harbor"
Statement
To the extent any statements made in this release contain information
that is not historical, these statements are forward-looking statements
within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, as
amended, and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as
amended, and may be forward-looking information within the meaning
defined under applicable Canadian securities legislation (collectively,
"forward-looking statements"). These forward-looking statements relate
to, among other things, our objectives, goals, targets, strategies,
intentions, plans, beliefs, estimates and outlook, and can generally be
identified by the use of words such as "believe", "anticipate",
"expect", "intend", "plan", "will", "may", "target" and other similar
expressions. In addition, any statements that refer to expectations,
projections or other characterizations of future events or circumstances
are forward-looking statements.
Although Biovail believes that the expectations reflected in such
forward-looking statements are reasonable, such statements involve risks
and uncertainties and readers are cautioned not to place undue reliance
on such statements. Certain material factors or assumptions are applied
in making forward-looking statements, and actual results may differ
materially from those expressed or implied in such statements. Important
factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from these
expectations include, among other things, the risks detailed in our
Management Proxy Circular and from time to time in our filings with the
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and the Canadian Securities
Administrators, as well as our ability to anticipate and manage the
risks associated with the foregoing. Additional information about these
factors and about the material factors or assumptions underlying such
forward-looking statements may be found in the body of this news
release, as well as under the heading "Risk Factors" contained in Item
3.D of Biovail's most recent Annual Report on Form 20-F.
The Company cautions that the foregoing list of important factors that
may affect future results is not exhaustive. When relying on Biovail's
forward-looking statements to make decisions with respect to the
Company, investors and others should carefully consider the foregoing
factors and other uncertainties and potential events. Biovail
undertakes
no obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statement, except
as required by law.
About Biovail Corporation
Biovail Corporation is a specialty pharmaceutical company engaged in
the
formulation, clinical testing, registration, manufacture, and
commercialization of pharmaceutical products. The Company is focused on
the development and commercialization of medicines that address unmet
medical needs in niche specialty central nervous system (CNS) markets.
For more information about Biovail, visit the Company's Web site at www.biovail.com.
For further information, please contact Nelson F. Isabel at 905-286-3000
or send inquiries to ir@biovail.com.
Source: Biovail Corporation
Biovail Corporation Nelson F. Isabel, 905-286-3000 Vice-President,
Investor Relations and Corporate Communications
|